Mr. Scaruffi defines this band as the first American brit-poppers.
Songs like "Go, Hippie", the seventh, with a very Oasis-style sound might rightfully suggest this.
In reality, this band formed by the singer-guitarist Collington and the multi-instrumentalist Schlesinger carries forward a light and catchy sixties sound made of tracks that at first listen only have a pop flavor. They hide, and not even all that well, a great study of melodic American '60/'70 music with catchy choruses, very friendly sounds, and an enviable compositional variety.
The attempt to paint in watercolor hues the American province (even revealing its false myths and the underlying deceit of the AMERICAN DREAM) is truly splendid in "Utopia Parkway" which owes much also to the flower movement and the happier and less experimental psychedelia. If you don’t believe me, listen to Amity Gardens, the ninth track, then pick up any album by The New Pornographers and ask yourself how many times this record has been played on the stereos of the Canadian band that's now become the spokesperson of the more colorful revival-flower-power movement.
"Utopia Parkway" from 1999, a moderate success in America that went unnoticed here, is representative of the band’s sound and is, in my opinion, their best result. "Red Dragon Tattoo" and "Denise" are immediately enjoyable tracks that do not hide remarkable harmonizations and sound care, to the detriment of the lyrics, which, in Fountains tend to be a bit simplistic.
The other reviews you might find around always dismiss them as Beach Boys sound or unfortunate band, but I don’t believe a band’s success is determined by whether or not they are known overseas. Certainly, it doesn’t automatically make them Losers, who in fact are quite the opposite even in style. Meanwhile, here in Italy the Fountains of Wayne, mentioned in an episode of 'The 4400', have become a place: in one of the episodes a blonde girl invites one of the protagonists for a weekend at the fountains of Wayne where everyone would go for a concert...
A great album to listen to in the car at a significant volume when stuck in city traffic.