Cover of Extreme Waiting For The Punchline
dark schneider

• Rating:

For fans of extreme, lovers of 90s rock, readers interested in melodic and classic rock album reviews
 Share

THE REVIEW

Hello everyone. Today I happened to listen again to a CD that I really liked a lot in the second half of the 90s. It's called "Waiting for the Punchline" and it is the last work by Extreme, a band famous for having written one of the most beautiful ballads of the past decade, "More than Words" (later covered in Italian by Jovanotti).

Compared to their previous works, the album sounds darker, more melancholic, and strangely mean, especially considering the previous album had love as its central theme, possibly also due to the change in lineup. In fact, the work opens with "There Is No God", a song that I find very beautiful and gritty, alongside a trio of catchy yet at the same time edgy songs. "Cynical Fuck" quite drags you in, and "Tell Me Something I Don't Know" is sophisticated and enjoyable, with the following "Hip Today" being very nice.

The album then takes a bad downturn where the beautiful instrumental "Midnight Express" stands out. The CD then recovers with "No Respect", a gem that gives you the right energy to confront the "Evilangelist" of the next track, which is unusual for their style. The last track we find is "Shadow Boxer", which concludes Extreme's career in their own way and with the style of their past works.

What I liked about this CD. The skill of the four guys, especially Gary Cherone with a truly spectacular voice (perhaps slightly sacrificed here) and Nuno Bettencourt (can anyone tell me if he's related to the one from Angra?) truly talented.
What I didn't like. Truth be told, I liked everything when I was thirteen, but listening carefully now, it seems here and there I've already heard some things around. And then, by the time they emerged, there were already countless bands like them, and significantly better (who said Guns, Red Hot, Van Halen...).

In short, a CD that in the end doesn't have much to say, but is well-made and evokes good memories for me.

Loading comments  slowly

Summary by Bot

The review revisits Extreme's 90s album 'Waiting For The Punchline,' highlighting its darker, more melancholic sound compared to previous works. While musically skilled and featuring standout tracks, the album feels less original amidst contemporaries. The reviewer applauds the band's talent but views the album as well-made yet somewhat forgettable overall.

Tracklist Lyrics

01   There Is No God (06:08)

03   Tell Me Something I Don't Know (06:25)

04   Hip Today (04:42)

05   Naked (05:47)

06   Midnight Express (03:59)

Read lyrics

07   Leave Me Alone (04:47)

Read lyrics

08   No Respect (03:52)

09   Evilangelist (04:49)

Read lyrics

10   Shadow Boxing (04:35)

11   Unconditionally (05:05)

12   Fair-Weather Faith (04:50)

13   Waiting for the Punchline (06:01)

Extreme

Extreme are an American hard rock band formed in Boston in 1985. The classic lineup features Gary Cherone (vocals), Nuno Bettencourt (guitar), Pat Badger (bass) and Paul Geary (drums). Blending hard rock, funk, and metal, they broke through with Extreme II: Pornograffitti and the worldwide hit More Than Words, followed by the ambitious III Sides to Every Story and the raw Waiting for the Punchline. After a mid‑90s split, they reunited and released Saudades De Rock in 2008.
10 Reviews

Other reviews

By gemini

 Extreme have never bowed to the laws of the market.

 The album requires attentive listening to appreciate its refinements despite some weaker tracks.