DaveJonGilmour

DeRank ™: 1,09

DeAge™ : 7256 days • Here since 29 july 2006

Muse Black Holes And Revelations

27 mar 07

Voto:

HURRAY WELCOME TO THE COMMONPLACE FESTIVAL PLEASE TAKE A SEAT LADIES AND GENTLEMEN.. even Dark Side and Wish you were here and The Wall right? Come on in folks, there’s good wine here..

Muse Black Holes And Revelations

27 mar 07

Voto:

@Jim: the majority of critics panned Obscured by Clouds, The Final Cut, and A Momentary Lapse of Reason.

Muse Black Holes And Revelations

27 mar 07

Voto:

But precisely mixed, it’s not based on compositional innovations that I judge the 2 groups in question, but on something else, I’ve already told you, that’s why I prefer Symphony X. What do you mean by “it really means a lot”? More irony?? For now, I’ll refer you to The Divine Wings of Tragedy, which I’ve also reviewed and which is the best by Symphony X in my opinion.

Muse Black Holes And Revelations

27 mar 07

Voto:

It's not true that critics ruin half of the career of my favorite band... the majority of critics dismiss 2 at most 3 albums.

Muse Black Holes And Revelations

27 mar 07

Voto:

Well, what does this saying refer to now? To something I said? It doesn't seem so to me.

Muse Black Holes And Revelations

27 mar 07

Voto:

An album doesn't have to present a deep innovation to be a masterpiece --> did I perhaps say the opposite? I was just responding to Mista, who first mentioned innovation, saying that it’s lacking in both Muse and Symphony X, but I certainly don't condemn them for it.

Muse Black Holes And Revelations

27 mar 07

Voto:

A matter of perspective, indeed: their style is what it is, whether you like it or not. They have the guts, but a bit less compositional skill. Many today lack ideas, and in any case, they have more than the muses.

Muse Black Holes And Revelations

27 mar 07

Voto:

I was waiting for someone to contradict that... so I said "deep," and anyway, I wasn't absolutizing modern music as a whole, far from it.

The Alan Parsons Project The Instrumental Works

27 mar 07

Voto:

I agree with Pibroch, especially Lucifer was needed!

Muse Black Holes And Revelations

27 mar 07

Voto:

"The skill of a composer is not measured by the number of pieces they include in a song" --> Symphony X are more musicians than composers, while the Muse seem neither one nor the other to me.