DaveJonGilmour

DeRank ™: 1,09

DeAge™ : 7257 days • Here since 29 july 2006

Kansas Song For America

22 dec 06

Voto:

You see, dear MAH!, I don't compare records to each other, but I evaluate them within their musical context; otherwise, believe me, the records that would deserve 5 stars for me could be counted on the fingers of one hand.

Kansas Song For America

22 dec 06

Voto:

no protest bjork, I just realized late the standards of debaser, and I...sat on it?! :-)

Morgan Non Al Denaro, Non All'Amore Né Al Cielo

22 dec 06

Voto:

You’re right, Tom, Morgan cannot add without taking something away, and the voice is absolutely incomparable, of course. That said, this "difficult" attempt to recreate a Masterpiece by Faber has proven to be quite successful. @antoniodeste: thank you, best wishes to you too!

Nektar Remember The Future

22 dec 06

Voto:

Ahi ahi enrybaxx..."Middle"???

Kansas Song For America

22 dec 06

Voto:

I take this opportunity to wish well to those who believe that Christmas is a day different from the others, a simple goodbye to the new year to those who, like me, do not believe it.

The Casualties Under Attack

22 dec 06

Voto:

but those who talk about prog... I'm not really interested in delving too deeply into the punk discussion because it deserves it, it would just be a waste of time... evidently you have had more time than me.. I'm not saying they are stupid ideas but simply clones.. and the same goes for the music.. good luck

James Holden The Idiots Are Winning

22 dec 06

Voto:

if by "winning" we mean staying on the sidelines, then the title of this record is quite fitting

Charalambides Joy Shapes

22 dec 06

Voto:

But go fuck yourself

The Casualties Under Attack

22 dec 06

Voto:

Bisius, I will respond to your first question, the only thing I've read from your extremely long review: for me, punk is socially the ugly copy of the message for the youth of the previous decade, which was also taken up by grunge in the following decade. Musically, however, it means very little to me, considering that the old garage was much more original, at least... So even your last sentence, "they took nothing away and added nothing," could very well be attributed to any band labeled as punk. What can I say, I'm glad for those who find something in it... it’s not about being backward or finicky, just open your eyes (also to disdain many of the comments that will follow this statement)... Overall, good review, even if a bit lengthy.