Duane Banned

A fair review, I fully agree on the issue of "hitting all those who can’t stand duplicates, triplicates, brass, that perhaps in '73 hadn’t even been conceived yet, and act like they’re in the know about Progressive, Funk, and homemade Mediterranean cuisine"... perhaps the review could have been a bit more detailed, considering that the album doesn’t lack in ideas...

Since the issue of review quality continues to be raised, I want to make a small clarification: The first criticism directed at me concerns the fact that I analyzed the album track by track, while most of the reviews on the site limit themselves to getting rid of the records in question with an average of 10 to 15 lines... honestly, I don't see what this flaw in form is; I don't believe that excessive care in what one does is a defect. Moreover, alongside this "scandalous track-by-track analysis," I also include a more general comment on the album, so it cannot be asserted that I limited myself to a "mere" analysis of the tracklist...
The second criticism made to me by Mauri, namely that of an inflated review, I believe does not exist for a number of valid reasons:
1) On the site, there are those who inflate Mondo Marcio and the Blue, so I don’t see why I couldn't inflate this album.
2) Everyone refers to this album with terms like "grandissimo disco" (geenoo), "Il disco è Enorme" (mauri), I would like to understand why you only invoke anti-doping for me (regarding the inflation!!!). I believe it is now a unanimous judgment for those who understand something about music that this is the LIVE par excellence made by one of the BAND par excellence...
Geenoo, I've turned to you because criticisms have been directed at me, not that they are unfounded, but simply unmotivated by adequate explanation... in light of the clarifications mentioned above, what would these flaws be that Mauri has so evidently highlighted?

Given the music that’s going around these days, it’s better to remember these albums... :P

Everything's fine, Mauri, but you seemed a bit too harsh with my debut work... anyway, it wasn't me who hyped up the review, it was really them who were too pumped up to be genuine!!!

Great album, a bit of a copycat, but with some nice touches...compared to Mondo marcio and the Blues, this is a masterpiece!!!

Shame!!! We are talking about Blue, yet another record label gimmick to entice hysterical girls...

Response to the two comments...
1) to ajejebrazof: the review is true, it was already there, but you can't dismiss this album in 10 lines... Betts is certainly not Duane, but he is still huge... he never fails to hold his own next to the legend...
2) to Mauri: dear Mauri, it's legitimate that you may not like the review, but in my house, statements also need to be justified...

Great album, great Led Zep!!!