Pibroch

DeRank ™: 2,00

DeAge™ : 7402 days • Here since 5 march 2006

Genesis Foxtrot

8 aug 07

Voto:

@Manliuzzo: listening to it again, it can remind me of Gentle Giant, but I don’t think the song contains any quotes. I might be wrong, I am the first to admit my ignorance when it comes to musical details… ;-) @Sirbony: if a suite includes two minutes of honey interspersed with 72 hours of time in 17/4, it’s not really considered pop, is it? That today they would build an entire album around a tune like that is another matter, and perhaps in that sense you’re right; but the context of “Supper's ready” is something else entirely, it’s monstrous. I bow in admiration. God, those bells, what chills...

Pendragon The Window Of Life

7 aug 07

Voto:

It seems interesting, you know? Great tip. A few inevitable little mistakes (I still make some despite having 30 reviews under my belt) aside, you write well too. Here you go. ;-)

The Banshee Public Talks

7 aug 07

Voto:

Cut&paste (which is actually copy&paste) a bit less. We have a wonderful language, let’s use it.

Genesis Foxtrot

7 aug 07

Voto:

More than anything, a good album that has never been reviewed is becoming an increasingly rare commodity: if it is poorly described, it only breeds discontent and various ire, because perhaps someone was eager to sing its praises in a fifteen-thousand-verse panegyric.

Genesis Foxtrot

7 aug 07

Voto:

@manliuzzo: I personally have only written unpublished reviews. Of course, if the level of a review already in the database is that of the first review of the magical "Thick as a Brick," maybe a (good) duplicate is better. ;-)

Alan Parsons Try Anything Once

7 aug 07

Voto:

Nothing less, no really: great album for the legendary Alan. Cheers.

Genesis Foxtrot

7 aug 07

Voto:

Beautiful yes "Watcher of the sky," but in my opinion, after the soup, the standout track of the album is the stunning "Can-utility and the coastliners." Babba bia! One note, though, regarding the score of 1 following the vote (which was incorrect): it's not a great sign of civility; a "Foxtrot" might not appeal to everyone. The review is nonetheless very respectable. Best regards.

Syd Barrett The Madcap Laughs

7 aug 07

Voto:

Sure, those statements about Gilmour, mmmh... There are some good or excellent guitarists out there, but expressive ones like Gilmour, really, really few.