emanuele

YOSIF | Date: 28/6/2009 14:31 | Rating: — | Album Rating: —
Back In Black by AC/DC has sold over 30 million copies and yet remains an album of extremely high quality -> but no..
it's true... it sucks sorry, I was wrong, it sold 42 million records :)

Following the reasoning of DeBaser, or rather its reviewers, an artist or an album has a credibility inversely proportional to the success achieved. This is because if the artist sells, it means they are "commercial," "sellout," and "sold out."
But that's not necessarily true. Back In Black by AC/DC has sold over 30 million copies and yet remains an album of great quality, just like many albums by Queen, Led Zeppelin, King Crimson, Genesis, and I could go on.
As for the rest, decent review, well done :)

Dismantle, dear god, I'm not saying that you are the first to harm his person. The fact is that, as MAH says, you do it jokingly (those who have been around the site for a while know that you always maintain a light tone even in criticism), but the truth is you take it lightly, and it can bring a smile. Many, in a delusion of omnipotence, start to insult, and it becomes heavy. If I found myself with a ton of recipes under a review, I wouldn't say I would be offended, because it's nothing more than a review, but for a moment I would feel a bit hurt, that's all. I hope the criticism didn't bother anyone.

No, of course not, but come on... do whatever you want, I just say that you’re way more annoying than Dream Theater reviews, and I mean that. Moreover, half the people who post those comments, when they write reviews, only produce astronomical crap. Maybe before trashing certain reviews, one should take a good look at their own. Anyway, I repeat, do whatever the hell you want, you’re not changing my life, you’re just making me lose the desire to visit a site I've known for almost five years and that I've always admired. But hey, one less user doesn’t change anyone’s life :)

It's true that if someone wrote a recipe under a review, I would feel completely taken for a ride, dear sfascicarrozze. This is what was being said yesterday about another review in this group.
Okay, yes, there are way too many writings about Dream Theater, and in 99.99999% of cases they are completely useless, often made with the intent to attract hateful comments (I don't know, maybe some people actually enjoy being insulted), but you continue to not understand that it's just as annoying to read such comments under reviews (extreme cases, when people start writing all sorts of nasty things, and THIS is definitely not your case).
Yes, okay, this review is totally unnecessary, definitely useless, but was it really necessary to fill space and write a review? You know how many will come here just to show off how cool they are (yeah, saying we hate Dream Theater is super cool now) and will start writing recipes, poems, when they are actually far less modest reviewers than those who write about DT?
God, I've been so convoluted; I just wanted to say, enough with these silly comments, especially you, sfascicarrozze, who make us laugh more when you write those strange but delightful reviews, or when you negatively comment on reviews like my very first one on Bathory :D.
Cheers... oh, I almost forgot in all of this... reviewer, don’t take it personally, but this really is over the top.

It may be a little movie, but I like it, and I really enjoyed the review as well. Very well done :)

You may not have noticed, but you are light-years more annoying with your idiotic and pompous comments than the thousand reviews about these damn Dream Theater. You are truly irritating, in bad taste, often rude, and bordering on madness. A random comment can be funny, maybe even two, three; then enough, it becomes redundant, annoying, really too much, just like the reviews of this bunch of prog-wankers. That said, coming to the album... the best from SFAM, which wasn’t that great to begin with, I give it three just because it’s slightly more bearable than those two pieces of crap that precede it. The review isn’t badly written, but there was already another one telling us how this album is megagalactic (or presumed to be so). Bye.

yes yes...it's the classic album by maudlin of the well, lucky that they exist.
let me say it, I LOVE THEM.

I liked the review... I think I’ll pass on the album just for the ideology behind it. I don’t know how you managed to listen to it, you’re a brave memento :D...
Hmm, one note, the track by track, other than that, good job.
The 1 for the album is out of trust ihihih.

beautiful album, equally great review