S4doll

DeRank ™: 2,48

DeAge™ : 7646 days • Here since 6 july 2005

Robert Rodriguez - Frank Miller Sin City

14 apr 07

Voto:

beautiful and imperfect, the concrete example of how absolute fidelity (almost, Quel Bastardo Giallo isn't exactly like that in the comic) can simultaneously be both the strength and weakness of a work. The dialogues that fit so well with the characters on paper often come across as over the top and excessive here. The excess of zeal and the inability of the directors to make any minimal personal choices prevent the film from reaching levels of excellence. As it is, it's a perfect adaptation, but it lacks a bit of courage.

Cameron Crowe Jerry Maguire

12 apr 07

Voto:

where would eyes wide shut be a great film? it's the worst kubrick film

David Lean Doctor Zhivago

12 apr 07

Voto:

an immense pain in the ass, I wouldn't see him again even under torture

Alejandro Gonzalez Iñárritu 21 Grammi

10 apr 07

Voto:

not that "original" necessarily has to rhyme with "paraculo" and "pretestuoso." This film is take it or leave it; if you don't like it, you can always give it a 2, but giving it a 1 as if it were garbage is not a sign of open-mindedness. You might have every reason in the world, but this is not a piece of crap.

David Cronenberg The Brood, La Covata Malefica

10 apr 07

Voto:

how can you like Crash and not like eXistenZ...

David Cronenberg The Brood, La Covata Malefica

9 apr 07

Voto:

not bad, but he has done better

Zack Snyder 300

9 apr 07

Voto:

Ghemison, stop doing drugs :D seriously, the limits are precisely in the fact that it doesn't deviate much from the comic (like Sin City and its adaptation), which is why the dialogues aren't great... it's a good adaptation, actually it's excellent (something has been lost, of course), the problem is that the comic itself wasn't anything transcendent. It's enjoyable and better than the films listed by Ghemison (though you only mentioned trash), except for Sin City which has little to do with the genre (and which, by the way, I consider to be of better quality).

E.B. Clucher Lo Chiamavano Trinità

9 apr 07

Voto:

I quote the Venusian, Poletti what do you say? When "Trinità" came out, there were already Lino Banfi and Alvaro Vitali around; this film is deliberately devoid of a certain type of vulgarity, not censorship at all. Whether you like it or not is subjective, but equating it to stuff branded Boldi-De Sica doesn’t exist at all.