Ghemison

DeRank ™: 2,99

DeAge™ : 7813 days • Here since 19 january 2005

Jay-Z The Kingdom Come

29 dec 06

Voto:

I didn't know that Sfascia was an editor. In the meantime, I discover something positive: at least the dwarfs read the reviews. Certain things (like this one) are published that really give the impression that there is no kind of oversight.

Jay-Z The Kingdom Come

29 dec 06

Voto:

"If the artist 'hadn't retired publicly.' Sorry, but if you start a hypothetical period, you'll have to conclude it, right? And that's not the only mistake of this kind... Example: what the hell does 'More philosophical than the previous albums, his statesman-like perspective on songs like '30-Something'' mean? The predicate is missing; the sentence is completely nonsensical. And then what would 'grandinato' mean? Sorry, but think before you write. There's a difference between distraction and what seems like a total ignorance of grammar on your part. I don't want to offend you, but please proofread the reviews before sending them. Do everyone a favor."

Outkast Idlewild

28 dec 06

Voto:

Great OutKast! Sacred monsters (for me, I have to say it otherwise someone will find something to say)... The review is a bit weak and confusing. Carlino, you missed a great opportunity to keep quiet (in my opinion). I need to listen to the album.

Kelly Clarkson Breakaway

28 dec 06

Voto:

Regarding the voting disc. If a review expresses a taste that I do not share but is well-written, I don't know whether to vote positively. Simply because through the review, a thought is conveyed that I do not agree with. Therefore, I try not to vote.

Kelly Clarkson Breakaway

28 dec 06

Voto:

"This review is well-written but expresses a taste that's truly terrible." In a single statement, you expressed two opinions as if they were law. Why as if they were law? I said what I think, did I offend you? Well, I'm sorry, I didn't mean to. But can I no longer express myself freely because it might offend you? Every time I speak, do I have to preface it by saying it's just my personal opinion? That seems obvious to me.

Kelly Clarkson Breakaway

28 dec 06

Voto:

I didn't mean to offend you, and I spoke only for myself; I didn't present myself as an authority. For me, this is infantile pop, from MTV in the worst possible sense. It's clear that if I read a review giving 4 to records like this, I think it's a taste of shit (for me, at least). Maybe you're an expert in classical, jazz, etc... but I didn't criticize your tastes in general. Rather, I was referring to the record in question. No hard feelings.