c'è Banned

DeRank ™: 12,64

DeAge™ : 7211 days • Here since 14 september 2006

Led Zeppelin In Through The Out Door

31 jan 07

Voto:

And then experimentation is something entirely different, just look at Tim Buckley’s Starsailor, Wyatt’s Rock Bottom, etc., not Led Zeppelin’s In Through the Out Door. Sure, you can hear new instruments. But this certainly doesn’t benefit the value of the album. An album shouldn’t be judged by how many new instruments are used in it!

Led Zeppelin In Through The Out Door

31 jan 07

Voto:

So according to this reasoning, Led Zeppelin II is a piece of crap because it doesn't formally bring anything new compared to the first album, and yet this one, because it experiments with whistles and synthesizers, is positive? So why do you only give it 3 stars?

Led Zeppelin In Through The Out Door

31 jan 07

Voto:

The truth is that the hard rock of Led Zeppelin, with the rise of punk first and the explosion of metal later, would not have found space in the '80s. I believe that the breakup would have been inevitable anyway.

Led Zeppelin In Through The Out Door

31 jan 07

Voto:

Well, you see, after In Through The Out Door Page says he really intended to return to the distinctly sounds of Physical Graffiti. I'm not saying it. And Plant will say it in many of his later interviews as well.

Led Zeppelin In Through The Out Door

31 jan 07

Voto:

The premise you make at the beginning is wrong; the only yardstick for judging a Led Zeppelin album is to compare it to their previous ones, starting with those that are chronologically closest. And the comparison doesn’t hold up, as you honestly say.

Led Zeppelin In Through The Out Door

31 jan 07

Voto:

It's a review that's too fan-like, as highlighted in the last paragraph, even though it’s very heartfelt. The album has been torn apart because in some parts it's really embarrassing, just like those whistles.

Led Zeppelin In Through The Out Door

31 jan 07

Voto:

And then the very fact of conforming to new musical trends has, in my opinion, been a significant fall from grace rather than an experimentation. And this album represents anything but an artistic rebirth.

Led Zeppelin In Through The Out Door

31 jan 07

Voto:

It’s not true that they wanted to continue down this path, but then Bonzo died. They wanted to get back to making a much harder album, in the style of Physical Graffiti. And for the rest, I fully agree with what the green manalishi says, as he has hit the point.

Led Zeppelin In Through The Out Door

31 jan 07

Voto:

Led Zeppelin III is experimental, not this album here. And what do you mean by experimenting? The whistles in Fool in The Rain? The Led Zeppelin, just a few months after the release, distanced themselves from this album and immediately planned to make another one with a more pronounced rock approach because, as Page himself said: "we listened to All Your Love and said: that's not us." But Bonzo died and nothing came of it. To be honest, I don't really like double reviews (in this case, it's a triple), especially when there were already 2, and Miki Page's was really well done, and with all due respect, a lot better than this one.