c'è Banned

DeRank ™: 12,64

DeAge™ : 7211 days • Here since 14 september 2006

Francesco Guccini Guccini

10 sep 07

Voto:

However, if it's true that someone who insults has reached the end of the line, then you started when you were truly at the end of your rope. And then I'm the one who contradicts myself.

but don't you see that you're a die-hard fan? You have all his albums, you know what Dario Fo thinks, you know what Gianfranco Fini thinks, you know what the pope thinks. But why don't you talk about music? What Fini thinks doesn't interest me. Music is derivative, too much for my taste. I go to the movies to see one of those nice capitalist films that I like so much, maybe American, sure.

Francesco Guccini Guccini

10 sep 07

Voto:

Are you now resorting to insults? From what pulpit? Is Guccini a politician? Maybe you just can't read. And anyway, really, from you, who went and gave Valerio Rivoli all ones out of spite, I won’t accept lessons, because you’re just a little kid. Valerio gives a 1 to my review of the great Guccini? Then I'll give a 1 to all his reviews, so he learns!

Francesco Guccini Guccini

10 sep 07

Voto:

politicized zero? but what do you mean by politicized? that it talks to you about the financial budget or the "scalone"? or the gross domestic product? Don Quixote, I’m surprised you haven’t understood it, if you’re such a fan as you say.

Francesco Guccini Guccini

10 sep 07

Voto:

"December 3rd, '39"?

Francesco Guccini Guccini

10 sep 07

Voto:

"Don Quixote" from Stagioni, do you know it? It seems to me like a very clever song.

Francesco Guccini Guccini

10 sep 07

Voto:

I have 7 of these famous 20 albums, and the only one I find interesting is Radici. Should I mention other songs that refer to communist social politics as a homework assignment? And then it seems to me that we agreed there's nothing wrong with making politicized music. This is my comment: "(and whether it's right, left, up, down, yellow, or blue, I don't care at all)," this is yours: "provided that making politicized music in itself isn't bad."

Francesco Guccini Guccini

10 sep 07

Voto:

But excuse me, are we playing a game of moving the goalposts? First, you tell me it has nothing to do with politics, then you say it does relate to politics but it doesn't make politicized music, then you ask me in which song, I tell you, and you say there's no political message (the lyrics are clear though). For heaven's sake, I admit that with you the discussion is civil, which is something that's impossible with Babel. However, it seems to me that we're playing the "yes, but..." game.

Francesco Guccini Guccini

10 sep 07

Voto:

"Song for Che" do you know it? Does it seem symbolic enough to you? Stay with the benefit of doubt. But know that your "I know the opposite" represents nothing to me. 90% of the information I know about music I read on the internet, 90% of the music I listen to I download from the internet. That's why I write on debaser. And whether you like it or not, these are indeed words in freedom.

Francesco Guccini Guccini

10 sep 07

Voto:

I read it on the internet, he himself says it, in response to a precise question about his political significance. You tell me he doesn't make politicized music, I say he does (as for whether it's right, left, above, below, yellow, or blue, I couldn't care less). And I wanted to remind Babel, who acts so superior, that he is the same person who, upon seeing a negative (and debatable) comment from Valerio Rivoli, went through all his reviews to give 1 star to every album and every review without even reading one. I wouldn't be so self-righteous.