Untitled Page

Afterhours I milanesi ammazzano il sabato

9 may 08

Voto:

You are out of your minds!!!!! I think I'm unsubscribing from Debaser!!!! The whole world is praising (rightly so) this great album and you are slandering it!!!! Are you for real???
And for the record, what a drag with these excuses...beautiful music, great lyrics, refined sounds (listen to "La mia città" on headphones to believe it)...and Manuel is a poet, yes! screw Montale who was the king of self-referentiality!!!!
You are a cult, this Debaser is becoming a place for the paranoid...you are worse than the grillini...to quote Manuel "you criticize everyone so as not to criticize anyone"....man, how crazy it is!!!!
And to anyone who wants to trash the album, I say: go ahead, you wouldn't have space on your HD for Britney and Tokyo Hotel!!!!!

Afterhours I milanesi ammazzano il sabato

8 may 08

Voto:

And there you have it... here we pretend to vote on the review "as such"... in reality, it’s about being for or against the After... at this point, instead of talking about form, let’s say something about the content... starting from the fact that Manuel Agnelli is a great poet, the album is phenomenal, musically rich, original... sought-after sounds... and wonderful lyrics!

Afterhours I milanesi ammazzano il sabato

8 may 08

Voto:

In Italy, everything is done “at random”… or rather, as they say in Taranto… a uecchj!!!!

Afterhours I milanesi ammazzano il sabato

8 may 08

Voto:

All along the watchtower VS I'm not imaginary...the Cure...
So, a review that contains nonsense (because it is nonsense! where did the Cure come from???) cannot be evaluated independently of the work being reviewed...
Okay, we are in Italy and content no longer matters...but a review that spouts nonsense, even if well written, cannot be rated highly! And to know if it’s nonsense, you have to be familiar with the work...so those who haven’t heard the album and vote are, in my opinion, making a mistake, period. And it’s no coincidence that people vote 1 or 5 depending on whether they’re fans of the after!!! Come on, please!!!

Afterhours I milanesi ammazzano il sabato

8 may 08

Voto:

All along the watchtower VS I'm not imaginary...the Cure...
So, a review that contains nonsense (because it is nonsense! where did the Cure come from???) cannot be evaluated independently of the work being reviewed...
Okay, we are in Italy and content no longer matters...but a review that spouts nonsense, even if well written, cannot be rated highly! And to know if it’s nonsense, you have to be familiar with the work...so those who haven’t heard the album and vote are, in my opinion, making a mistake, period. And it’s no coincidence that people vote 1 or 5 depending on whether they’re fans of the after!!! Come on, please!!!

Afterhours I milanesi ammazzano il sabato

8 may 08

Voto:

Re-read what I wrote about Borges... anyway, this review is awful!

Afterhours I milanesi ammazzano il sabato

8 may 08

Voto:

"if I listened to all the records from the reviews I've read"....that you have READ...
I still believe that rating a review without knowing the subject of the review is not a smart idea...unless you’re scoring the language, the form...as if it were a newspaper article...there’s a book by Borges that contains false reviews (I believe it’s Chronicas de Bustos Domecq)...so you’re right to criticize the "principle"...but in this particular case, this review doesn’t seem worthy of a Strega prize!

Afterhours I milanesi ammazzano il sabato

8 may 08

Voto:

Sorry...today I'm a bit out of it... anyway... you can start any philosophical rant, but I think it's foolish to vote on a review of something you don't know... considering it wasn't written by Umberto Eco... my friend read insults directed at the After and voted 5 on a review... that's all... and it's really sad!

Afterhours I milanesi ammazzano il sabato

8 may 08

Voto:

Sorry, my previous comment got sent again...
But doesn’t the review actually review THE ALBUM???? The truth is that you voted not on the review but on the insulting content towards Afterhours... and let's face it, this review is quite pathetic, it's even poorly written!

Afterhours I milanesi ammazzano il sabato

8 may 08

Voto:

Sorry, my previous comment got sent again...
But doesn’t the review actually review THE ALBUM???? The truth is that you voted not on the review but on the insulting content towards Afterhours... and let's face it, this review is quite pathetic, it's even poorly written!