jettero heller

DeRank ™: 0,00 • DeAge™ : 4250 days

Love
  • Contact
  • Here since 13 december 2013
Best Progressive album of all time
<b>Hatfield and the North</b> • Hatfield and the North

5

Hatfield and the North • Hatfield and the North

<b>Gilgamesh</b> • Another Fine Tune You've Got Me Into

8

Gilgamesh • Another Fine Tune You've Got Me Into

Your comment on the chart
Comments on this chart
  • macaco
    macaco
    23 jan 14
    More Canterbury than progressive.
     
  • TheJargonKing
    TheJargonKing
    23 jan 14
    Indeed, I would say it's almost a Canterbury ranking with some intrusions. Hot comments more related to taste, but just to talk: From Cos (great Belgian combo) I definitely prefer the first Postaeolian Train Robbery. From VDGG, I love every single second, but The last we can do is around the 4th position for me. Renaissance, according to my taste, I would have placed Turn of the Cards. The presence of Tonton Macute, Second Hand, and Cressida is a bit strange, especially at the expense of (for example) King Crimson. Anyway, all great albums; it's just a matter of taste and to foster the debate. Well done.
     
  • jettero heller
    jettero heller
    23 jan 14
    there was no canterbury among the site choices otherwise I would have separated...as for the tonton macoute...well, more prog than them!!! I link them to the sound of cressida's "asylum"
     
  • jettero heller
    jettero heller
    23 jan 14
    there was no canterbury on the list... that one by Tonton macoute is a nice prog I'd say!!! I assimilate their sound to the Cressida of "Asylum"
     
  • TheJargonKing
    TheJargonKing
    23 jan 14
    It's not a discussion of whether to include prog or not, but rather of prioritizing them over King Crimson, Soft Machine, Yes, Gentle Giant, Genesis... that seems a bit "particular" to me. Or when talking about Canterbury, why include the Cos and not National Health or Henry Cow, for example.
     
  • mal
    mal
    23 jan 14
    you have to give us yours one day, Jargon
     
  • TheJargonKing
    TheJargonKing
    23 jan 14
    I believe I’ve already done it, but I’ll check; otherwise, I’ll do it.
     
  • mal
    mal
    23 jan 14
    Ah yes, like "best work". Seen it now!
     
  • rolando303
    rolando303
    24 jan 14
    If we didn't have all these labels like jazzrockprogrockfusioncanterbury and whateverrock, wouldn't everything be much simpler?
     
  • TheJargonKing
    TheJargonKing
    24 jan 14
    We live by labels, you couldn’t do without them either. And how could you possibly put Henry Cow, Genesis, Tangerine Dream, Area, Dream Theater in the same pot???
     
  • rolando303
    rolando303
    24 jan 14
    The problem is that then a whole series of inconsistencies come out and everyone has their say. Once there was jazz, blues, and rock. Stop.
     
Similar users
Afropazzo

DeAge 4252

silviab30

DeAge 4254

zubba

DeAge 4254

rocknbeat1210

DeAge 4254