Cover of Discharge Why
g.g.junior

• Rating:

For fans of discharge, lovers of hardcore punk, punk history enthusiasts, readers interested in punk music and anti-war themes
 Share

THE REVIEW

Hardcore can be described with many adjectives: aggressive, nihilistic, anarchic, confusing, rebellious, and the list goes on. The first wave of HC punk can simply be identified by one name: Discharge.

Not at all ambitious in the technical and compositional side, their sole intent was to shock with short songs, concentrated into a few chords, with lyrics of a few lines screamed in a heartbreaking manner.

The main theme of "Why" is the total refusal of war, the massacre of innocents, the unjust use of military forces, against capitalism. There is no better word to demonstrate the complete misunderstanding of all this than with a single question mark: "Why?", why does all this happen before our eyes and no one can do anything about it? Again, "Why". Not only the title track has this theme, almost the entire album carries this message.

"tomorrow tomorrow

A look at tomorrow

Hysterical men woman and children

run in search of their families

I look out of my window

to a blinding bright light

Enola passes passes by"

All this description of sad war scenarios is enriched by the raw images in the booklet: dead children piled on the stairs of a building, bodies of murdered families, left on the ground with eyes wide open from fear, people in tears trying in vain to revive their massacred loved ones, Discharge still have no other words except "Why".

All this work is played in an almost epileptic manner, noisy and confusing, sung without melody, screams of desperation that make us empathize with the anguish of war, with fear, and in their way, they want to make us feel ashamed of our indifference, of our potential power enclosed in comfortable society; we have what we want and we don't care about anything that doesn't concern us. Deafening solos performed without the slightest technical execution skill suddenly burst in the middle of songs, constant distortion, poorly recorded, does all this have any value? No, "Why" aims solely at revolution, music is secondary.

Discharge influenced many future bands, it's said that speed metal, Slayer's or Metallica's thrash, fast and aggressive music originated from them. All I have to say is that the theme of this album, released in 1982, has become relevant again today, a historic album that everyone should own.

Loading comments  slowly

Summary by Bot

Discharge's 'Why' epitomizes raw, aggressive hardcore punk with its blunt anti-war message. The album rejects musical complexity for raw emotion and directness. Its themes focus on war's horrors and societal indifference. Despite low technical skill, the music's power lies in its intensity and message. 'Why' is a historic, influential record still relevant today.

Tracklist Lyrics Videos

01   Visions of War (01:41)

02   Does This System Work (01:17)

03   A Look at Tomorrow (01:57)

05   Maimed and Slaughtered (01:06)

Read lyrics

06   Mania for Conquest (01:16)

Read lyrics

07   Ain't No Feeble Bastard (01:30)

Read lyrics

08   Is This to Be (01:31)

09   Massacre of Innocents (Air Attack) (01:23)

10   Why (reprise) (01:49)

11   State Violence / State Control (02:42)

Discharge

Discharge are a British hardcore punk band formed in 1977 in Stoke-on-Trent, widely recognized as pioneers of D‑beat and a major influence on thrash and extreme metal.
03 Reviews