"Nightmare Anatomy" is an album that can either greatly excite or deeply disappoint.
The main flaw of its predecessor, "Our Gangs Dark Oath," lay in the way the songs were structured, which felt a bit unripe.
In "Nightmare Anatomy," on the contrary, the tracks achieve a formally perfect compositional structure, yet extremely linear and quite similar for all the tracks on the album, except for the opener "Knife Blood Nightmare", which indeed seems to have come straight out of "Our Gangs...".
Surely, this album will delight fans of emo-punk in the style of early My Chemical Romance, with its flawless formula, even if a bit overused by now. Distorted guitar riffs, "dark" lyrics (a bit monotonous), killer choruses in abundance, alternated singing between clean (and very unique) vocals and screams, tasty background choirs, and a drumming that pounds hard across all 11 tracks, all in the name of the highest catchiness.
Definitely a more polished and appealing product than "Our Gangs Dark Oath," yet it is hard not to miss the variety and "authenticity" of its predecessor.