Personally, I've always described the 3 Doors Down as a band without too many pretensions. If you look through their discography for complex riffs, virtuosic solos, or similar things, you won't find them. I define them as a group that makes music just for fun, for taste, for pleasure. And you can feel it clearly already in their debut.
"The Better Life", marked 2000, is an album without particular pretenses. It starts with "Kryptonite", a song that goes "If I go crazy then will you still call me Superman". Oh, if only I didn't have a visceral hatred for the old man with the diaper (and by the way, there's a funny old man with a diaper in the song's video) I would like it more. It continues with Loser, one of my favorites from the album. "Duck And Run" starts off hard, with powerful guitar riffs, then flows into a catchy and enjoyable chorus, while "Not Enough" shows good ideas and fitting vocal lines put together with concepts not always well exploited.
Then we reach "Be Like That", a song hyper-commercialized by American Pie and friends, but don't dare call it a bad song. "Life Of My Own" is a somewhat static piece, requiring multiple listens to appreciate. The title track has a different style compared to what we've heard so far, with Hard Rock riffs and the gritty voice of Brad Arnold making it one of my favorites. "Down Poison" I classify (personally) as a monotonous filler. The worst of the album. "By My Side" has some good ideas not fully exploited, making it an understated song compared to the previous ones (except "Down Poison"). It concludes with the pseudo-punkish "Smack" and the beautiful "So I Need You".
In short, "The Better Life" - belonging to the much-despised post-grunge trend by music purists - is great for those looking for catchy and free rock, but if you look beyond this, you won't find much.
Be kind in the comments, it's my first review... xD
"Kryptonite is a crescendo of melodic energy."
"3 Doors Down did not bring anything new to rock but well applied the teachings of the post-grunge era with heart and technique."