COX

The vote was for the rece...

A perfect album and then you give it 3 stars?

The moment will come when you'll add this aspect as well, and I'm sure you will. The fact that you reviewed such an artist is indicative of the beginning of a certain journey; moreover, you have a writing style that I personally enjoy—it doesn't bore.

Review that I didn't like for various reasons. First of all, you didn't even quote half a piece, yet it’s a beautiful album (your words) and as such, shouldn’t it deserve a better description? I would have liked to read about parallels between the tracks on this album and those that are most representative of the period you are examining (Duke Ellington especially).
I don't know the album; personally, I am not a fan of bop and hard bop, and I listen to a different genre of jazz (like modal jazz, for example). Starting from this assumption, which sets us apart as listeners, I find Basie a must for every jazz listener.
There are some good insights in this review, such as this one: "This album has the ability to open the doors to an ancient world, but not dusty, swing and smiles, concert halls (ballrooms), the roaring '20s of the States and the gloomy '30s. Atomic Basie is from 1957, but smells of pre-war." But as far as I'm concerned, everything is too vague. I need to get the album.

I won't go below a two. I should, the album is absolutely empty and banal (in the long run, after repeated listens even stale) but I love Pink Floyd and that makes me less harsh towards their nonsense. Your review manages to eclipse the (poor) quality of the product. It's as if a product worth 0 cancels out what is worth 2 (even though it's not a two, I repeat).

Much better the second album, the time of joy.

Great big group, we know it with just a handful of people.

The review is well-written, as evidenced by the fact that I’m now eager to listen to Rather. However, you could have focused more on the tracks of the album.

Boring, verbose review with constant self-referential digressions. In simple terms, you’re not writing about the film but rather giving yourself a handjob, placing emphasized accents on your knowledge (which the reader cares little about). Enjoyable movie but not a great one.

Collections are the ruin of music, and reviews of collections make me laugh. Do you want Pink Floyd? Then listen to their albums and please don’t review them since Debaser is full of reviews (many of them poor) about Pink Floyd.