bjork68

DeRank ™: 0,24

DeAge™ : 7311 days • Here since 3 june 2006

The Beatles Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band

16 jun 07

Voto:

john winston, I cited the piper to stick to an exclusively British theme, and as you say, it’s important to highlight what was happening across the ocean because, after all, it all started there. But the velvet in '67 were even more decisive with white light white heat than with the banana, at least I prefer it; I find it more radical and seminal.

Yes Fragile

16 jun 07

Voto:

but what resentment, I have other things to think about, you know? That doesn’t change the fact that what I told you is true; in fact, some anonymous people don’t hesitate to let you know it cowardly, while I’m telling you personally. I think you are musically competent; I don’t see why you should waste yourself on angry comments, insults, as you usually do. Then it’s up to you, behave however you want, but don’t be surprised if someone later points it out or misunderstands you.

Yes Fragile

16 jun 07

Voto:

And you, what do you know instead of me? You're the first to tell certain reviewers that they don't understand a damn thing, and in a rude way. Your way of expressing yourself is always unpleasant when you want to criticize. And by the way, you’re the one who goes into the prog reviews to say that it’s crap, if I’m not mistaken, you’ve definitely done that! That’s why maybe I misunderstood what you wanted to say. And anyway, I agree with your last post.

Yes Fragile

16 jun 07

Voto:

And then sorry, fusillo, it was logical that Italian prog would also lead to melodrama; it's part of our culture! And for this singular episode, it seems exaggerated to assert that progressive music relies on 19th-century classicism. If you are only referring to Italian prog, well, I don’t even care to spend words defending it; that’s a bore, unlike Yes :-)

Yes Fragile

16 jun 07

Voto:

oh no fusillo wait, you're talking to me about Italian prog, which I don't like. I was referring to British prog.
no, no progressive controversy, the conversation is civil as you can see, for once.

Yes Fragile

16 jun 07

Voto:

I don't understand why ridiculous, Pippo. Maybe you meant it skims the ridiculous and the kitsch, but I hope you don't generalize. Of course, it’s excessively cerebral music and to many it seems not driven by the heart, but to give two very simple examples, I would hardly consider Suppers Ready or Close to the Edge heartless, arid, and sterile, and definitely not ridiculous. I thought you appreciated prog music more, Pippo :-))

Yes Fragile

16 jun 07

Voto:

what was I saying about nirvana??? I didn’t even mention them!

Yes Fragile

16 jun 07

Voto:

but where did he see the nineteenth-century work in the prog? who knows! talk about what you know.

Yes Fragile

16 jun 07

Voto:

Many progressive bands have inspired musical movements that came after, like vdgg, Faust, and Rush, to name a few. And some little presumptuous guys talk about it as if it should be erased from the face of the earth! Oleeinar, even Red is liked a lot by those who don't love prog, but if you think about it, the King Crimson are the ones who have strayed the most from the genre, despite having legitimized it with In the Court. They are undoubtedly the most creative and experimental among English prog bands, having explored a wide range of sounds, and I would challenge anyone to say they don’t like at least one of their works, they are so varied and different. Van der Graaf even appealed to Johnny Rotten, if I remember correctly.