But can someone tell me what nonsense some of you are writing? Queen and Led Zeppelin? Dante and Tasso? Camus? Guys, have you been on some unknown drugs?
So: Music isn't just about "pure" technique; otherwise, three quarters of rock (except perhaps Progressive) would be flushed down the toilet... Secondly: I've always been indifferent to critics! I've been listening to music since I was still in my mother's womb, I have 2000 CDs, and I've listened to at least 10,000 classical albums (from Madrigals to Rachmaninoff, and recently Nyman), rock (from Elvis Presley to Muse...just to name one contemporary...through all its incarnations), Blues (from Bessie Smith to BB King), Jazz (from Cole Porter to Patricia Barber or Michael Brecker and Pat Metheny), Avant-garde (Reich, Eno, Riley, and many others), New Age, electronic, more or less cultured...So? I’m the greatest critic in the world!! And let someone dare to say otherwise! No, guys, we’re not on the same page... Music, like art in general, is something subjective, "emotional," and can't be reduced to the cold mathematical calculation of "scales" and "chords"...
There are those (as someone rightly pointed out) who have never picked up a guitar and have composed immortal works (I think of Autreche, Future Sound Of London), while others have made the guitar come alive again (Hendrix, Gilmour, Blackmore, Vai, Metheny, Santana, McLaughlin, etc...)... So what?
Another thing: just to clarify, "The Divine Comedy" has received (rightly so) the success it deserves because it was the first great "work" of modern literature...Before "it," there was nothing, and to find something similar, we have to go back to the times of the Greek-Latin classics... The rest (extraordinary works like The Jerusalem Delivered and I also think of Paradise Lost by Milton, not the band, huh?) came later...
See, in music, it also matters (especially in rock) who gets there first and makes it "public"...
Speaking of The Divine Comedy, legend has it that one day in the year of our Lord 1300 and something, Dante was walking through the streets of his city when suddenly he stopped, captivated by the clumsy "singing" of a "craftsman" coming from a workshop... Dante recognized those murmured, whistled words right away!!! It was his work! Like a whirlwind, he rushed inside and smashed everything within reach (the chronicles do not say if he also smashed the head of the careless sharpened :-))) What does that mean? It means that even an ignorant shopkeeper could read it, understand it, and even whistle it!!
Great Zappa, vaudeville united with rock, classical, jazz, and everything else that came his way... But how many people are able to understand it? 1 in 100,000... The Queen, on the other hand, were understood by everyone, because their syntax was still simpler, more accessible... So accepting as true the discourse made by this RICCARDO, let’s throw out Tom Waits too... Patti Smith was a charlatan!!! The Velvet Underground weren’t exactly musically refined... Keith Richards plays guitar like my grandpa in a wheelchair after a stroke!! My friend Francesco plays guitar 10,000 times better than him... Yet he hasn’t composed "Satisfaction" or "Jumpin' Jack Flash"...
Guys, let’s regain a sense of reality. "A Night at the Opera" is one of the cornerstones of the '70s.
Best regards