StefanoHab

DeRank ™: 1,96

DeAge™ : 7787 days • Here since 11 february 2005

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart Concerti per pianoforte K 466 e K 482

12 feb 06

Voto:

I don't like Mozart and the neoclassical pompousness; I greatly prefer the Romantic period (Beethoven and Chopin especially). Great review anyway! Finally, something different!

Nesli Ego

12 feb 06

Voto:

Rap is totally outside my interests, but the review is beautiful, original, and intriguing. Well done!

Alessandra Celletti Overground

12 feb 06

Voto:

In fact, I’ll go further: you did well to write it. I’m glad that this way you can be known; you’re modest and you write well, and the same idea was nice. The only thing I want to emphasize is that it’s not a review, that’s all. Bye Alessandra.

Alessandra Celletti Overground

12 feb 06

Voto:

But I didn't say anything contrary, just to be clear. I said one very simple thing: an artist cannot review their own album because otherwise what they've written cannot be called a review. This is a simple fact. Stop, period. I didn't mean to offend anyone; in fact, if this were a real review, I would say it’s really nice. Let’s say it’s a nice non-review. I certainly didn't say to remove it or anything like that; I just expressed my point of view (which, to be honest, isn’t personal: it’s the same definition of a review, a principle that applies to everyone). That’s all. I invite you not to misunderstand my words, nor those of Punisher... got it, committee???:-)

Alessandra Celletti Overground

12 feb 06

Voto:

No no calm down, I understood perfectly, I'm not questioning anything, neither the review itself nor the reason why it was written... The only thing I'm saying is that the fact that I played on that Arkhamian album is fundamental! You can't say "I don't care"! If I had played on that record, I couldn't have reviewed it; it would have been a self-review, something completely nonsensical as it would lack any criticism! Sorry, but it's pretty obvious!!! That's all I wanted to say, it was a general statement, I wasn't referring to Alessndra. I'm just saying that artists can't write their own reviews, that's it.

Kayo Dot Dowsing Anemone With Copper Tongue

12 feb 06

Voto:

Eh eheh... and that fool Bruce Springsteen?? Would you ever call him rock???

Korn Life is Peachy

12 feb 06

Voto:

Why? Korn are strong but Tool often screw them over.

Alessandra Celletti Overground

12 feb 06

Voto:

I understand, it seems nice that you want to promote the album, but it really is a matter of principle: a review is not a review if the reviewer is the one who recorded the album! That's just the foundation of it all. Don't take it as a provocation (in fact, I didn't play on that album I reviewed). It couldn’t be simpler! For the rest, I wish you good luck.