Giubbo

What bothers me about this album is that there's a certain adolescent "emo" approach that disrupts the excellent folk ballads. Oh, and then "the latest thoughts" is pretty awful: Britpop. Rating: 3.5.

Punisher, tell me something useful: since you only review albums that you find bad, I absolutely don't trust someone who doesn't appreciate anything. However, since you've mentioned somewhere that you review good things under another nickname... tell me what that other nickname is. I would be very disappointed if you were to laud historically significant albums that are universally recognized as masterpieces. Why don’t you do the opposite of your nickname "Punisher"? In other words, why not review well albums that are universally recognized as rubbish? You would demonstrate that you have a personality and a "two-sided" taste in evaluating things.

great northern. I've been eyeing this for quite a while, but the funds are low. tell me a bit: is the album in the style of the 12 minutes of visiting friends (in sung tongs)?

Look, Punisher, what you've written above is the first humble and open post for dialogue that you've written (I don’t understand why you insist on hiding the fact that you also possess intelligence). On the other hand, don’t call me angry when you hold the throne of such a species. Third: it’s true that “already heard” is already in itself a merit for criticism... too bad that in 100th Window there is not a trace of “already heard,” indeed that album was not liked by most precisely because of the NEW proposal made by the Massive, too advanced for the dull ears of the masses. As for Sigur Rós, it’s true that maybe they are starting to recycle themselves too much, but it’s a shame that they recycle THEMSELVES, a concept that has been deemed genius by most people, unlike the Libertines and their lovely friends so dear to Rumore, who recycle others, showing a complete lack of musical talent.

fat of the land is a piece of easy shit. I said it the day after its release, when sales were zero. I wondered if it was really the same group that churned out jilted. It’s laughable.... but please. narayan is very beautiful, for heaven’s sake, climbatiza too, but the other crossover crap with a ridiculous keith flint...

Well done, punisher, keep tearing apart. Damn it, you really are a badass punisher. The record labels fear you now. If your job is to tear down, you’re not doing it well since you always justify everything with "they’ve already done it," like that famous review of 100th Window that I certainly haven't forgotten, a potpourri of monumental crap.

well then

absolute masterpiece

the fat of the land obviously is crap. this is a masterpiece. I've never seen such a low leap between two subsequent albums. I also agree that experience was too naive. I absolutely do not agree about the narcotic suite, in my opinion it's the acidiest peak of the album.

welcome back sodoooooo... everyone says they have class to sell but they're really heavy. also check out the new lightning bolt