Giona

DeRank ™: 4,33 • DeAge™ : 6364 days

Contact
Here since 16 february 2008

Genesis Live in London 1974

15 mar 08

Voto:

I listened to it again... indeed, I think we’re talking about the same album, XBend... In my opinion, in some parts Gabriel takes a few too many liberties and excessively reinterprets some vocal passages... anyway, if he can't afford it, who can? The others are, as always, flawless.

Rainbow Long Live Rock 'n' Roll

15 mar 08

Voto:

I’m out of the discussion and I have no intention of getting involved, nonetheless I have to give a round of applause to the Judge because he made me double over with laughter!

Genesis Live Over Europe

15 mar 08

Voto:

Well, you're a bit mean... maybe I'm just too attached to the group and perhaps I'm slightly losing objectivity, but to call them even unbearable... This may not be a masterpiece, but it's a nice live performance after all (of course, I understand your templar point of view, since we've talked about it before, but despite their changes, I still enjoy listening to them quite a bit... more or less :))

Genesis Live in London 1974

15 mar 08

Voto:

"Fierce criticism"? XBend said he wanted to improve at writing reviews, and my telling him to be careful not to repeat the same terms too often does not seem to me to equate to having eaten him alive... In case it wasn't clear, I didn't mean to criticize you for no reason, XBend; I wanted to give you some advice.

Gilgamesh Gilgamesh

15 mar 08

Voto:

Um...no...I would definitely say no...

Genesis Live in London 1974

15 mar 08

Voto:

You have a bit of a problem with the repeats... notice it... Then, as for the album, I think I have it but I should listen to it again before rating it... I definitely have a bootleg with the same setlist dated back to 1975... I don't know if it's the same one you're talking about...

Gilgamesh Gilgamesh

15 mar 08

Voto:

@OleEinar: Let's take it philosophically and say: "better few but good ones."

Giles, Giles & Fripp The Cheerful Insanity Of Giles, Giles & Fripp

14 mar 08

Voto:

The album is enjoyable even though it’s not really a high peak...the review is clear but somewhat brief...you didn’t even mention "Erudite Eyes," one of the most interesting and experimental tracks on the album...

Genesis Selling England By The Pound

14 mar 08

Voto:

Agreed with Psycroptic. Anyway, let's not start talking about who eats whom... please.

Gilgamesh Gilgamesh

14 mar 08

Voto:

Thank you all! @ thejargonking: In fact, the other works truly deserve a lot as well, but if I really had to choose one, I might lean towards this one.