luciano

DeRank : 0,17
DeAge™ : 8423 days • Here since 18 may 2003
Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin IV
Voto:
??? but why, at 17, do you have to be light? light in the sense of superficial or light in the more complete sense of being foolish? Well, just to be safe, it’s better if I leave; otherwise, I might end up arguing even in here...
Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin IV
Voto:
Anyway, don’t take it personally for the four; it’s probably the best four-star review I’ve found published online so far, and I hope you can appreciate a well-motivated four from me rather than a five from some random Rivo (at Rivo, you owe me your helmet; you still haven’t understood that!).
Thanks for the promptness; I take it as a consideration towards me. Bye.
Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin IV
Voto:
Ok, given the premise that everything I don’t specify goes perfectly (especially the selection and the point where some historical gems are inserted), I’ll tell you: A) the matter of names is overstated compared to the whole media operation; the "cause-effect" relationship of the expectation on the hype doesn’t come through; B) thanks for the importance of 3° (actually, I remember reading that Jimy Page's first comment on 4° was made upon the release of 3°: "our next album will earn us a place in rock history or be a complete flop" or something like that; C) "Active" and "fickle" don't appeal to me at all; if I understood correctly what you mean, I would have translated them to "nervous," at most "electric" (although it lends itself too much to interpretations in other directions). In this regard, combined with the lack of attention to punctuation, it makes me think of a not perfect mastery of the language. After all, who knows what would come out if I tried to write something in Flemish :-) D) I’ll grant you the carpet for "the battle of evermore," but then "Black Dog" and "Rock and Roll" are the curtain; E) Stairway to Heaven is tough; F) the description of the tracks should respect the order in the album, out of respect for those who are not familiar.
27 aug 03
Voto:
AAAAAAAAAAHHH, I told you to delete it! Just change the tense of the final clause (a detail, but important)!
DELETE IT, IT MAKES NO SENSE! What is it, a punishment for my effort in organizing the multiple reviews? REMOVE IT IMMEDIATELY!!!
Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin IV
Voto:
In the meantime, before we even read, let’s stay true to the promises made...
Black Sabbath Paranoid
Voto:
Note to Coppino: remember us when, at thirty, you climb onto the wardrobe to dust off Paranoid and, listening to it, you think: "well...".
Hello, actually YAOOAOAAOOAOAO.
Black Sabbath Paranoid
Voto:
2 clarifications: A) "...the history of hard rock..." B) you could have made it just a bit more exhaustive, perhaps citing some parts of the album that, when borrowed, have built hits (heavier metal than hard rock, actually) that many metal kids sing at the top of their lungs, excited. Nevertheless, I reward you because reviewing this masterpiece in this database feels like winning away in the Champions League in Munich. Thank you, bye.
Note for Rivo: I’ve understood what I’d like more from you, I would like you to make an effort to research the historical importance of an album, to place it not only based on how it sounds, but also for what it represented or (much more challenging) for what it will represent. Once you do this, you can even sell me the helmet and I’ll set up a Rivo fans club.
Hi everyone.
Pink Floyd Atom Earth Mother
Voto:
I'm nudging you because I'm interested in how you listen, and I'm convinced that with a little more attention and time when you write, you could help elevate the level of the database. Let's say that in potential, you are among the top 3 I've noticed here. For a career as a professor, perhaps, I could be inclined, but they pay little and I've already turned down two assistant positions. Win a prize if you guess which subject (it's small because it's easy to guess). I gave you a "2" because I deducted a point for each imperfection: I expect quite a lot from you. Regarding "Turin Brakes," I believe, in general, that having listened to something that is reviewed, it's important to contribute to others’ reviews, even if the work doesn't seem that great; in that sense, I renew my invitation. By the way, voting poorly for the "discacci" (although I always mean "in general," Turin Brakes don't seem terrible to me at all), could bring the rankings of the most liked De-Dischi back to reasonable positions... Hasta luego.
Richard Ashcroft Human Conditions
Voto:
The album evokes real emotions in me: pity. A note of demerit to the reviewer who re-reviews an album that has already been reviewed, with the aggravating factor that it’s a pure disaster. Best Regards.
Pink Floyd Atom Earth Mother
Voto:
Anyway, D) I'm waiting for your comment under "Ether Songs" by "Turin Brakes"; E) "for you" is written without an accent... Tschuss.