giampy1985

DeRank ™: 0,00

DeAge™ : 7204 days • Here since 18 september 2006

Paul McCartney Memory Almost Full

26 may 07

Voto:

I, on the other hand, agree with kosmogabri. Macca has shown that he cannot handle the biennial release or, worse, the annual one. Chaos came after 4 years of waiting, Flaming Pie after 4, Flowers in the Dirt after 3. Moreover, there’s the same old story: Macca chooses his collaborators poorly. Kahne is certainly not on the same level as Costello, Lynne, or Godrich. Macca needs someone to challenge him, in short, someone who can also get on his nerves when necessary. Well, when you listen to the album, you’ll understand why there's a lack of passion and feeling in the review... and you’ll long for Chaos...

Paul McCartney Memory Almost Full

25 may 07

Voto:

ahahah, well, you are right Deneil... the thing is that when it comes to the Beatles, I consider myself knowledgeable enough to write good reviews, while for other artists I could just share my opinion without writing anything interesting...
I’d say classic rock, like the Rolling Stones, Pink Floyd, U2, Elvis, Led Zeppelin... Also Italian singer-songwriters... Other genres I touch on without going deeper (pure pop, metal, indie, jazz-rock, prog)... Urgh, it’s pretty hard to define what one listens to! :D

Paul McCartney Memory Almost Full

25 may 07

Voto:

For Deneil, I don't see the problem if someone then buys the album in question. On the contrary, I believe it is very useful to find a preview opinion for those people who don't know how to get an album before its release.

Paul McCartney Memory Almost Full

25 may 07

Voto:

I may not have written a super-review and I accept judgment, but what I cannot accept is a PREjudice: from your comments, you have shown that you did not vote on a review but simply on the fact that it precedes the release of the album.

Paul McCartney Memory Almost Full

25 may 07

Voto:

data collection?
Including the introduction with historical preamble and assumptions about the album release?
Including the analysis of the main theme of the album?
Including references to the sound and themes of past albums?
Including the summary and final analysis?
Well, thank goodness it's just a data collection...
If you were less snobbish and overlooked the accessory detail of the release date, maybe you could evaluate what needs to be evaluated, which is the quality of the review.

Paul McCartney Memory Almost Full

25 may 07

Voto:

"The records should be listened to more calmly and not to rush the reviews"... so what were you referring to? I've been listening to the album for over a week, which seems more than enough to write a good review.

Paul McCartney Memory Almost Full

25 may 07

Voto:

El Guevo, does it seem like a rushed review to you? But have you even read it?

Paul McCartney Memory Almost Full

25 may 07

Voto:

El Guevo, does it seem like a rushed review to you? But have you even read it?

Paul McCartney Memory Almost Full

25 may 07

Voto:

a little bird gave it to me... or rather, a mule...

The Eagles Their Greatest Hits, 1972-75

22 may 07

Voto:

but at least inform yourselves before writing a review... "Their Greatest Hits 1971-1975" is indeed one of the few albums that have surpassed the remarkable figure of 20 million copies worldwide. But "Thriller" celebrated reaching 104 million copies in 2006, so there’s no comparison...